Facebook  Twitter  Youtube  ISSUU  RSS  Email

Media Contacts

UK
Dominic Kavakeb
dominic.kavakeb@transparency.org.uk
+ 44 (0)20 3096 7695
Out of hours: Weekends; Weekdays (17.30-21.30): +44 (0)79 6456 0340


Twitter

TransparencyUK "The Morning Risk Report: U.K. Raises Game on Social Impact Investing" via @WSJRisk https://t.co/bejzuHXPIq
16hreplyretweetfavorite
TransparencyUK RT @kathryn_higgs: Dr Mo Ibrahim: Transparency - in particular beneficial ownership - is one of the top 5 challenges facing businesses toda…
TransparencyUK "Corruption scandals show why leaders should highlight ethics" via @FT https://t.co/wAoD16Ug3O

Tag Cloud

Allegations anti-bribery anti-corruption summit anti money laundering bribery BSkyB Cabinet Office Chart companies conflict Corporate Cooperation corrupt capital Corruption corruption in the uk employment film financial secrecy Governance Government health Home Office illicit enrichment intern journalists Letter Leveson Inquiry London Merkel money laundering offshore tax open governance pharmaceuticals PHP Prime Minister Register of Interests Research Resources Social Accountability statement Trustees UK Unexplained Wealth Orders unmask the corrupt UWO vacancies

Stay Informed

Sign up for updates on TI-UK's work & corruption news from around the globe.

Corruption and banking: FOREX heralds an important change in rhetoric

Written by Robert Barrington on Thursday, 13 November 2014

This week’s announcement about the rigging of the foreign exchange markets marks one significant change: at last the media and the Chancellor are using the word corruption to describe this behaviour.


 

Osborne: ‘Today we take tough action to clean up corruption’

This week’s announcement about the rigging of the foreign exchange markets marks one significant change: at last the media and the Chancellor are using the word corruption to describe this behaviour.

Since the financial crisis started in 2008 banks have been fined tens of billions of dollars for regulatory breaches; regulators have been found wanting and have been reformed; new rules have been put into place; politicians, the media and civil society have ranted.  But the word corruption has seldom been used.

So why is it used this week?  Most obviously the behaviour of the FOREX traders fits naturally into most standard definitions of corruption, including TI’s own ‘the abuse of entrusted power for private gain.’  But perhaps there is something more.  Among the public and the world at large, there has been a lingering feeling of unfinished resources-resources-business – that the banks have got away with it, that the really senior individuals who allowed the system to get out of control have escaped with their large pensions or been allowed to continue with the mildest slap on the wrist.  It may be that this latest scandal is the straw that beaks the camel’s back. Of course, banks themselves will be hoping for the opposite: that this series of settlements, however large, draws a line under the past and allows them to get on in a new and better-regulated world, with a different cast of characters at the top.  It is certainly striking how many of the comments from the guilty banks and their trade bodies are following the ‘few rogue individuals’ argument.

Does it make a difference to describe this as corruption?  Yes in three important ways:

  1. Corruption is very seldom the result of a few rogue individuals.  It is enabled by a system that lacks transparency oversight and accountability, which themselves often indicate institutional complicity that allows those higher up the food chain to reap the rewards while distancing themselves from the illegality.  It is striking that in the survey of corporate transparency that TI released last week the average score for financial services was a paltry 32%.
  2. Corruption is difficult for individual companies to tackle.  In this case it will require banks, regulators and very possibly civil society to have a sensible discussion about the real nature of the problem and how they can work collaboratively to improve the situation.  It may have been FOREX and LIBOR yesterday, but tomorrow it will be something else – unless there is a fundamental change in integrity among financial institutions.
  3. The remedies for corruption are difficult long-term and challenging to the resources-resources-business models of the status quo.  The mindset of banks, regulators and politicians needs to be that a ten-year clean-up plan is necessary – with the commitment, resources and continuity to see it through.

So here are three suggestions as a starter:

  1. Admit the problem.  Banks and their trade bodies have been in denial – settling each scandal individually but without concluding that the system is corrupt, and that should govern the nature of the response.
  2. Show leadership.  There have been some fine words from the new leaders in British banking – will one of them have the courage to admit that the problem is systemic corruption and build the consensus for systemic change?
  3. Stop the contradictory lobbying.  There is little trust in banks and whatever remains can easily be undermined by their own lobbying, in which private messaging contradicts the public statements of contrition.

London should not need dirty money and dirty deals to thrive.  It will be better served though a reputation as a financial market with probity and integrity.   It is also in the interests of society and the economy that the City’s huge and influential institutions are forces for good and not complicit in systemic corruption. Yet this week we have had the Chancellor describe the behaviour within its leading institutions as corrupt.  Is this just a change in rhetoric or a recognition of a more profound problem than has hitherto been acknowledged?

3767

Read 3767 times Last modified on Tuesday, 24 November 2015 11:47
mm

Robert Barrington

Robert is TI-UK's Executive Director. You can view his full bio here, and tweet him @TIukED.

Leave a Reply

Contact Us | Sitemap | Privacy

UK Charity Number 1112842

Transparency International UK is a chapter of